Re: [OT] How many integers?

new topic     » goto parent     » topic index » view thread      » older message » newer message

Hello Matt:

> Igor Kachan wrote:
> 
> > I say, Russian is better for such the things  smile
> > We say "power of a set", not "size of a set".
> 
> If I were being correct, I really should have said
> the "cardinality of the set."  
> To my [native speaking american-english] ear, "size" 
> sounds better than "power".  
> (Plus my "proof" actually contains a lot of hand 
> waving that might not be clear to someone not 
> familiar with set theory.)
> ...and then Igor wrote:
> > Then, Russians say "multitude" or "host", not "set".
> > So, "power of the normal integers host" forces to think
> > about infinity first of all.
> > And "host" itself may be small - as "set" is something
> > small first of all.
> 
> "Power of the normal integers host" sounds like you're 
> talking about an army or something to me. :)

Ok, try "Power of the normal integers multitude"  blink

> Then again, the "power of the host" of 
> Russian words I know is a very small number.

What a problem? Learn Russian and you'll be all set.
Do you see that famous "set" again? 
"multitude" is much more clear term for this subject.
Russian is Russian, no?
  
> > Russian is good for such the things, isn't it?  blink

Do you see Russian is really good?

> Well, I've heard that you guys have some pretty sharp 
> mathematicians, so I won't disagree with you 
> (though IMHO it was a Frenchman who was probably the 
> greatest pioneer in this area--Cauchy--so I wonder 
> what the French would say?).

This is a German source, Cantor's theory, 
he was the first setman-hostman-multitudeman blink

> Guess it's another case of imperfect translations.

Yes, my "host", "power", "multitude" are just the 
reverse translation of that Cantor's theory terms 
from Russian into English.
  
> I still like english, BTW. :p
> 
> Matt Lewis

Ok, and I still like Russian, BTW. :b

Regards,
Igor Kachan
kinz at peterlink.ru

new topic     » goto parent     » topic index » view thread      » older message » newer message

Search



Quick Links

User menu

Not signed in.

Misc Menu